Feb 17, 2022
My mom is an Asian woman in her 70s with osteoporosis. She tried an oral bisphosphonate and had horrible esophagitis. She said never again, though she eventually tried an IV bisphosphonate. She had terrible flu-like symptoms. She said never again. But based on reports that symptoms are worse the first time, she tried the IV again the next year and fortunately experienced no symptoms. (Story used with permission, thanks mom!).
I tell this story because these issues don’t typically register as more than a nuisance for clinicians, who frequently don’t understand why their older patient with osteoporosis is not taking a bisphosphonate. But our patients are walking with their feet, and adherence to bisphosphonates for osteoporosis is poor and decreases with time.
When we have a medication with up front harms and downstream benefits, it’s critical that we consider the time to benefit, or how long it will take an individual to benefit from a test or treatment. Think of the 10 years it takes to benefit from colon or breast cancer screening, which is designed to detect slow growing cancers. For individuals with a life expectancy less than the time to benefit, the up front harms outweigh the downstream benefits.
In this context, we talked this week with James Deardorff and Sei Lee about their study of time to benefit of bisphosphonates for osteoporosis, published in JAMA IM. What they found somewhat surprised us: it’s pretty short, about 1 year!
Which makes me feel better about urging my mom to get treatment. Bisphosphonates are pretty darn effective, and act quickly.
We also discuss discontinuing bispohsophantes, and if we can use the same logic we consider when starting them.
Toward the end we talk about the launch of ePrognosis’ new Time to Benefit tool. This tool provides a clinical recommendation for starting/stopping medications and cancer screening based on the prognosis of the patient in front of you. See screenshot below. You can either access it directly here. I you use the Lee Schonberg prognostic index for community dwelling older adults you will be directed to the tool, and it will automatically place the life expectancy at the calculated prognostic estimate.
James and Sei requested a terrific song - Bad to the Bone - much better than the Hannah Montana Bone Dance song they threatened me with (maybe next time).